Showing posts with label Cinderella. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Cinderella. Show all posts

Friday, February 20, 2015

Cinderella Meets the Byronic Hero

Although I’ve blogged here before about 50 Shadesof Grey, and I recently blogged here about the persistence of the Cinderella myth, I’m going to bring it all up again. The much-anticipated 50 Shades film recently came out, just in time for that most horrifying of holidays, Valentine’s Day, and many of us literary folk have been scratching our heads as to why, exactly, a poorly-written, poorly-plotted, sex-negative “mommy-porn” has made so much money and appealed to so many women.

Mad, bad & sexy!
Lord Byron
To me, the reasoning is fairly simple, though I will caveat my argument with the fact that I have read the books, but I have not yet seen the movie. Going by the books, however, it seems pretty obvious that 50 Shades combines two (possibly three) very powerful cultural myths: that of the rags-to-riches story (cue Cinderella) and the rake-reformed (cue the Byronic hero).

Although 50 Shades began as a Twilight fan fic, it owes almost as much to Pretty Woman as it does to its vampire progenitor. Pretty Woman is obviously a reworking of the Cinderella story, but if we look closely, we can see that it is also a story about bringing a sardonic, isolated, and brooding billionaire back to life—just like 50 Shades of Grey.

The Byronic hero or antihero (your choice) has his own gravitational pull. He is mysterious, alluring, charming, brooding, prone to outbursts, and intellectually superior to those who surround him. He is doing penance for an unknown past sin, suggesting emotional vulnerability obscured by a carapace of irony and self-loathing. He is cocky, self-assured, highly intelligent and, of course, wildly attractive, handsome, sexy, etc.

It’s hard to find a television drama these days without a version of our beloved Byronic hero—named after Romantic poet Lord Byron who was described by a contemporary as “mad, bad, and dangerous to know.” The archetype of the Byronic hero draws on both Byron’s personality as well as on his works—such as the character Manfred in the closet drama of the same name. Other Romantic and Gothic texts took up the rough outlines of the Byronic hero and helped build up his allure.

Victor Frankenstein, Heathcliff, Mr. Rochester, Sherlock Holmes and Eugene Onegin are some nineteenth-century examples that contributed to the growth of interest in this type of hero. Today, the obsession continues with various Sherlock Holmes movies and shows (Elementary and Sherlock), Dr. House, the entire Batman franchise, Edward Cullen and now Christian Grey.

Michael Fassbender as Mr. Rochester.
He's so tormented! Don't you just want to make him a sandwich?
The idea that a woman could “fix” the bad boy Byronic hero and open his heart to love has been around a long time as well. In some cases, our heroines succeed (Jane marries Mr. Rochester, though only after becoming financially independent); in others, they don’t even bother trying (Cathy is her own kind of Byronic heroine in Wuthering Heights, one could argue).

One of the most alluring conceits in the 50 Shades of Grey series is, no doubt, that Anastasia Steele succeeds in reforming her rake and, even more potently, that it is her innocence, purity, and tenderness that tame the beast (cue the Beauty and the Beast myth). While outwardly the novels appear to be about Christian’s dominance over Ana (and many feminists have castigated the work for supposedly glorifying stalker-like, abusive behavior in romantic relationships), at the heart of the appeal of 50 Shades of Grey is the powerful notion that this young woman is the only person powerful enough and special enough to reform Christian and his sexual deviance.

One of the earliest press release photos
underscores the difference between Ana
and Christian: college student and
sexy billionaire.
Ana is so morally and emotionally pure, that not only is she a virgin before she meets Christian, but she refuses many of his monetary gifts. She doesn’t want him for his money—though ultimately his money is the other crucial part of the powerful fantasy and appeal of E.L. James’s novels. Christian is so wealthy, that Ana’s money problems are solved forever once they get together. His wealth means most people are at his command—but not Ana. Though she agrees (sporadically) to be his submissive in the bedroom, she is constantly challenging him. Although she is physically weaker, younger, and financially insolvent in comparison with her lover, it is actually Ana (the woman) in the relationship who wields the real (emotional) power—and who “wins” at the end of the novel. Winning here means helped Christian leave behind the world of BDSM (mostly, anyway) in exchange for domestic bliss (and “vanilla sex”).

That is a powerful fantasy. And that, to me, is why these books are so addictive. It’s not just the sex. And it’s not because all these women are yearning to be in abusive relationships. It’s because these novels draw on culturally-embedded myths: Beauty and the Beast, Cinderella, the Byronic Hero. Further, they take these myths and rework them into a female fantasy in which empowerment is only necessary insofar as you are able to change your sexy, brooding Byronic hero into a sexy, no-longer-brooding billionaire husband and baby-daddy. Thematically, thus, 50 Shades of Grey is not so different than Pamela or Jane Eyre.


No doubt poor Charlotte Brontë is spinning in her grave!

Now, don't misunderstand me...there is plenty that is problematic, to say the least, about these novels and the spin-offs they have engendered. But it seems worthwhile to look at them in the context of archetypes and cultural myths, for they reveal the persistence of certain ideas in our culture. Further, literature has always been a place in which to explore (and create) fantasies in a safe place. Eighteenth-century fictions presented their readers with heroines in sticky situations, often for the purposes of entertainment--not always for moral instruction. 

We can read Eliza Haywood's Fantomina, for example, as a text about a deeply misguided young woman brought to the brink of obsession by a man. Or, we can read her as a conniving, powerful young woman in control of her sexuality. Both Fantomina and 50 Shades illustrate certain persistent inequalities in our society without making a definitive judgment about these inequalities.

This is not to suggest that 50 Shades is important in any "literary" way. It's poorly written with ridiculous dialogue and flat characterizations. It's erotica, and by definition erotica is repetitive--there's only so many ways to go about that particular business. But the very popularity of 50 Shades and its protagonists is what makes them so interesting to consider.

Wednesday, January 14, 2015

The Cinderella Complex: On the lasting effects of Pamela

It is a truth universally acknowledged that the second half of Pamela is not nearly as interesting as the first half. The first half of the novel details Pamela and Mr. B’s strange S&M-type relationship which includes multiple attempted rapes, kidnapping, beatings and verbal abuse of Pamela at the hands of her future husband.

The second half of the novel draws out their engagement, secret wedding, meeting the neighbors and finally reconciliation with Mr. B’s sister, Lady Davers. Lady Davers takes a lot of convincing, as she herself is of the conviction that by marrying Pamela, his mother's waiting-maid, Mr. B has debased himself. As they argue, Lady Davers tries to show her brother the error of his ways by suggesting that his marriage is the same as if she had married her groom.

“[Lady Davers:] Where can the Difference be between a Beggar’s Son marry’d by a Lady; or a Beggar’s Daughter made a Gentleman’s Wife?

Then I’ll tell you, reply’d he [Mr. B]; The Difference is, a Man ennobles the Woman he takes, be she who she will; and adopts her into his own Rank, but it what it will: But a Woman, tho’ ever so nobly born, debases herself by a mean Marriage, and descends from her own Rank, to his she stoops to.”

Mr. B’s answer perfectly sums up a sentiment shared by many people in the Western world from the eighteenth century onward. Even now, one might argue, there are those who would agree with his statement.

Such a statement might have made sense in the eighteenth century, as legally, a woman became her husband’s property upon marriage back then. In England, she automatically lost her maiden name upon marriage, as well. For many decades, anything a woman earned was considered her husband’s or her father’s property, and her wages could be garnished by the man of the house and spent by him as he wished.

Thus, an eighteenth-century author like Samuel Richardson truly would believe that it was the man’s rank that determined his wife’s—never vice versa.

It’s much harder, I think, to understand why so many people still believe in this idea today. Women have joined the work force, we have entered into some of the highest spheres in the workplace, and we have made many strides towards equality. 

At the same time men are still the primary breadwinner in most families around the world—and even in the Western world. Many men still have a hard time squaring the idea that they might stay at home while their wives go to work—even as the numbers of “stay at home dads” increase. Similarly, the lack of childcare options in the US, coupled with the shortest amount of paid maternity leave in the Western world mean that it still makes more “financial sense” for women to stay home with the children while their husbands go to work. (Of course, the lack of any kind of paternity leave for fathers only exacerbates these trends.)
Even in 2011, only 9.5% of fathers are the primary care-givers for children.
That's nowhere near 50%...
On the other hand, to go back to the eighteenth century, there were many men and women who deplored the subordinate condition of women and who spoke out against it. Mary Astell, Anne Finch, the women of the Bluestocking group, Jeremy Bentham, and Mary Wollstonecraft are just some of the many writers, both male and female, who railed against the oppression and unequal treatment of women.

Were there any upper-class women who married far below them, in the manner of Mr. B and Pamela? Were there any writers who challenged Richardson’s implicit sense of righteousness that only a man could “ennoble” his wife—never vice versa? If my readers know of any, I’d be excited to hear about it.

Class is a slippery topic, more ephemeral, in some ways, than either gender or race. How do we identify class? Titles, money, family name, income vs. inheritance, position, tastes, and background all play a part. It is possible to be of a high class but to be poor (consider the impoverished nobility of the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries). It is possible to have wealth but retain lower-class tastes that taint one in the eyes of the upper classes (such as those who are deemed the nouveau-riche).

Pamela is considered so revolutionary precisely because it illustrates the changing categories of class in the eighteenth century. Pamela is allowed to be ennobled because she is so virtuous—but also, because she is so beautiful. In the novel, beauty and virtue are joined together, just as Mrs. Jewkes must be ugly because she has such low, evil tastes. Later female authors, like Frances Burney and Jane Austen, explicitly challenge the notion that beauty and virtue are always joined.

We can't get enough of Jane & Rochester!
Of course, it’s impossible to discount the far-reaching effects Pamela has on English literature. It’s hard to read Pamela without also immediately thinking about Jane Eyre, for example, and how Charlotte Bronte changes the ending so that Jane and Rochester are more equal—by making Jane financially independent. Even Pride and Prejudice is, to an extent, a rewriting of Pamela, where Lizzy is rewarded with a rich husband, but not for being a servile, virtuous virgin—for being an independent-thinking, witty young woman.

The Cinderella-complex that persists in all of these texts—and that still persists, even now, in popular films, television series, and best-selling novels—is perhaps the more disturbing phenomenon. As a culture we continually insist on telling young women that they should wish, hope, dream of having their problems solved by marriage to a handsome, wealthy man rather than becoming wealthy and powerful themselves…probably because wealthy, powerful women are much harder to control.



We love the myth of Cinderella so much, we've got 2 more film versions coming out, just this year!